How Fragmented Systems Can Hold Your Association Back
When looking into the usual technology pain points that member-based organizations face today, one issue pops up time and time again: fragmented systems. This is the patchwork approach of cobbling together different software tools.
But is a fragmented setup (like a separate learning, membership, and events platform) really that much of a setback? And if so, what’s the real solution? In this article, we are exploring exactly why such disconnected technology can hold your organization back. And, more importantly, we’ll explore how to bring those separate pieces together for a much smoother experience for your members!
What Are Fragmented Systems, and Why Are They a Concern?
When we’re talking about fragmented systems, we’re referring to either systems that operate independently, with no connection to one another, or systems that are integrated but still fail to work cohesively. An integrated system is a setup that keeps data consistent across two or more applications over time (Gitlin, 2023). In other words, when data is added, removed, or updated on one platform, the other connected systems accurately and consistently reflect those changes.
So, are there any drawbacks to this kind of setup? To be clear, multiple systems integrated together are not fundamentally dysfunctional, as they can work at times. However, that’s not to say there aren’t better options (because there usually are!). As your organization grows, your needs evolve and expand alongside it.
You may find yourself introducing new tools and functions to keep pace with your goals, and what once worked just “well enough” can quickly become a limitation! The more your operations scale, the more strain systems face in keeping up.
It’s fine when they all work together, but what if they don’t or they start to malfunction? The tricky part about integrated systems is that each third-party tool you implement only allows a certain level of integration. Mazurkiewicz (2023) explains that while your tools may work well individually, getting them to function together can be a problem! If your software cannot integrate, that’s the time you run into a fragmented systems problem.
4 Common Problems With Fragmented Systems
When disconnected tools pile up without proper integration or if integrations don’t work, you end up with what Noble (2023) calls a “Frankenstein Stack” or the fragmentation problem! Rather than operating as a single, harmonized system, the integrity of your operations and data management is trapped within individual applications. Especially when you run into integration issues, you can expect four “headaches”:
1. Manual Workload Multiplies
Manually copying data when “integrated” platforms start acting up can waste valuable time your team could spend on more exciting, high-value initiatives for your organization. What’s more, errors can sneak in, slowly compromising the integrity of your data and operations.
2. Your Data Gets Trapped in Silos
In disconnected systems, information gets scattered, duplicated, and sometimes even lost! This problem makes it really difficult to get a holistic view of everything going on in your organization. And the scary part? Security risks may increase when member information (especially sensitive one!) is constantly transferred between systems.
3. Members Feel the Friction
If your integrated system doesn’t offer a single sign-on (SSO) experience, members are forced to juggle several different logins and interfaces just to interact with your organization. Asking them to jump through these extra hoops introduces unnecessary friction that hurts engagement and makes them less likely to visit your platform!
4. Hidden Costs and Fragile Technology Drain Resources
Finally, stacking different systems comes with hidden costs, as each platform carries its own licensing, maintenance, and support fees. Furthermore, when a vendor updates their software, those fragile connections may potentially break, causing unexpected downtime and highly costly troubleshooting! And, adding salt to the wound, managing multiple contracts and vendors becomes an administrative headache that drains your budget and slows down your entire operation.
How a Natively All-In-One Platform Solves Fragmentation
Natively all-in-one platforms, such as those provided by Vocalmeet, are the way to go. Built from the ground up as a single, modular solution, it brings everything together. This means that one vendor provides all the modules your organization needs, without integrations! All the core features of a platform are built into the system from the start, rather than added through plugins or third-party tools. Features such as:
- Membership management and renewals
- Event and conference registration
- Learning management, course delivery, and credit tracking
- Financials, eCommerce, and reporting
- Automated communications and marketing
- Member portals, analytics, and community tools
- Content and website management
We know what you’re thinking: what’s the difference? Well, because it starts as a single system (in which all your data is connected), member profiles, registrations, and course completions link automatically, so there’s no need for double entry, and errors are fewer and farther between.
Additionally, this type of platform is perfect for scaling! Organizations can start small with only one or two modules (like learning management and assessments), then add more as they grow (like member management and event registration). It’s as easy as flipping a switch!
Combining systems such as your association management system (AMS), membership management system (MMS), and customer relationship management (CRM) software into a single, native platform creates a seamless experience for both your staff and your members.
Conclusion
We’re not here to pressure you if you’re happy with your current integrated systems. But think about it: you may be better off working with a platform that does it all with no extra fuss (and of course, no extra worry). Consider a better approach, one where you actively save money, cut down on tedious admin work, and prevent dreaded technical issues!
References
Gitlin, J. (2023, December 13). Two-way API integration: examples, benefits, and tools. Merge.dev; Merge. https://www.merge.dev/blog/two-way-api-integration
Mazurkiewicz, E. (2023, October 12). Solving the puzzle of fragmented systems with custom software solutions. Inwedo. https://inwedo.com/blog/software-solutions-for-fragmented-systems/
Noble, P. (2023, October 27). Beware of the “Frankenstein Stack” of data systems. Forbes. https://www.forbes.com/sites/paulnoble/2023/10/27/beware-of-the-frankenstein-stack-of-data-systems/
